Planners' Equity Resources
Urban planners shape the plans and decisions that affect every aspect of the built environment and the people that live there.
On June 5, 2020 the APA-IL published a statement in regards to the inequities in our society and how planners have a responsibility to work towards correcting that. You probably saw lots of emails about this topic from companies and organizations, but APA-IL wants to and is doing more than that. We understand the real progress is made after a statement is made or a Plan is adopted. Statements and Plans are good and necessary but meaningful action must be made in our daily work and lives in order to make progress. That is why we want to support our members by providing the following resources and opportunities.
We want to hear from you! Please help us provide meaningful resources and tools to you by emailing us, connecting with us on social media, and through our various events to make sure that we are supporting you in your work and daily lives.
Planners’ Anti-Racism & Equity Toolbox
Urban planners shape the plans and decisions that affect every aspect of the built environment and the people that live there. While we are generally not the decision makers; we serve as advocates and experts in the built environment and land use policy, which can have a profound impact on Black, Indigenous, and People of Color. Many times we are expected to remain neutral, but there are ways we can shape the narrative to guide decision makers to adopt equitable plans and policies. The APA-IL Chapter has compiled a comprehensive list of resources that address two things: 1) strategies for planners to enact change from the ground up, and 2) how a planner can be more educated in racial justice to be better allies in the community.
This is a dynamic document. APA-IL volunteers are continuously updating this document as new tools and resources are available. We welcome additions and comments.
What you can do as a Planner
Project Equity Checklist
For every project and policy recommendation, be able to provide answers to the questions below. Responses can be included in a staff report or project summary, to provide guidance to local decision makers.
- How does this project address equity? Consider the following:
a. Access to goods/services
b. Housing opportunities
c. Safety
d. Environmental justice
- Who does this project benefit? Who does it harm?
- How does this project impact the Black community?
- How does this project impact People of Color in the community?
- How does this project impact low-income members of the community?
Be an APA-IL speaker
APA-IL is dedicated to creating events that are diverse and inclusive both in subject matter and participation. Now, more than ever, it is important that we highlight and uplift unique perspectives in urban planning from those who may not usually have the opportunity.
APA-IL is collecting the information on diverse urban professionals interested in being speakers/panelists at future events. Our desire is to make space for those who are often overlooked. In order for our chapter to truly embody Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion principles, we humbly ask for your help in identifying yourself or others so that we can take action towards becoming a more inclusive organization that speaks to the needs of our profession. Our focus is specifically related to identifying urban professionals from underrepresented populations that include, but are not limited to, race, ethnicity, gender identity, sexuality, religious background, ability, etc., throughout the state of Illinois.
If you are interested, please emailing us.
Training for Public Officials & Staff
Ensure your community requires equity and inclusion training for staff and all elected and appointed officials (boards, commissions, advisory groups). While planners provide information and can help guide discussion, policies are ultimately determined by a selected group of decision makers. The training should include how to recognize and combat unconscious bias, which includes “in-person bias” or the tendency of elected officials to favor input from people that have the ability to show up at meetings. For many communities, the people most impacted by city policies are generally low-income and people of color who are least likely to show up at public meetings due to work and family obligations, transportation and communication barriers, and unfamiliarity with the system of traditional local government public meetings.
Resources:
- How to Recognize and Address Unconscious Bias in Local Government, National Research Center, February 2020
- Public meetings are broken. Here’s how to fix them. Curbed, February 2020
- Campaign Zero: Solutions. Campaign Zero
- Anti-Racism Training - Free for the General Public and Students, Diversity and Resiliency Institute of El Paso
Transportation: Complete Streets
The divide between mode split and safety highlights a pattern that is too common and disheartening: traffic violence affects people of color at levels higher than their white contemporaries, and is a function of which transportation modes are used. While there are exceptions for affluence, choice, and transit-rich central business districts, walking and bicycling rates are higher in communities of color, as is the traffic violence that affects them. Promoting complete streets isn't just a trendy, healthy, sustainable thing to do, it is our duty as planners to ensure transportation investments serve the needs of all users, and that we correct the wrongs of previous decisions that disproportionately harm vulnerable populations.
Resources:
- Bicycle Race, by Adonia Lugo, PhD.
- Race and Ethnicity in Fatal Motor Vehicle Traffic Crashes 1999 - 2004, NHTSA
- CDOT Vision Zero
- The War on Cars podcast
Development: Transit Oriented Development
New Transit Oriented Developments (TOD) bring with them the promise of access: getting to the store, work, and parks in walking distance or by hopping on transit. While this promise may hold true, studies show many new (and old) TOD neighborhoods are subject to rising property values and displacement of people of color. Equity is needed in all TOD planning.
Resources:
- City of Chicago Equitable Transit Oriented Development (ETOD) Policy, City of Chicago, 2020
- eTOD (Equitable Transit Oriented Development), Elevated Chicago
- Racial Equity: New Cornerstone of Transit Oriented Development. Race, Poverty & the Environment Journal, 2012.
Housing
Resources:
- Racial Residential Segregation and Exclusion in Illinois, Institute of Government & Public Affairs, 2009. This article explores the different kinds of housing segregation around Illinois, including black, white, and Latinx populations in several metro areas.
Municipal Budgeting
Every municipality spends a significant amount of staff, elected, and appointed official time to develop its annual budget. Ensure that funds are distributed equitably, so more funds are committed to areas and neighborhoods with the greatest needs. Explain to decision makers how good planning is a cost-effective way to improve public health and safety.
Resources:
- City of San Antonio Budget Equity Tool. This tool includes a set of questions to guide City Departments in assessing how budget requests benefit and/or burden communities, specifically communities of color and low-income communities.
- The Ins and Outs of Your City Budget, CityLab, 2020. Illustrated guide to municipal budgeting.
General Policy
Make diversity, inclusion, and equity an adopted city/village policy. Welcome the lived expertise of the diverse members of your community rather than relying solely on those with credentials.
Resources:
- Policy Link. A national research and action institute advancing racial and economic equity. Great tools and case studies.
- SPARCC (Strong, Prosperous, and Resilient Communities Challenge)- The initiative’s long-term goal is to change the way metropolitan regions grow, invest, and build through integrated, cross-sector approaches that benefit low-income people and communities of color. This includes a good summary of the initiatives happening in their 6 selected metro areas across the country and links to lots of other resources.
Self-Education: What you need to know about racial justice, race relations, and how to be an ally to Black and minority communities
Planning, Equity, and Social Justice
- The Planner's Beginner Guide to the #BlackLivesMatter Movement: A compilation of resources meant to be a starter guide for those looking to educate themselves on the #BLM Movement.
- America's Cities were Designed to Oppress, Citylab. Architects and planners have an obligation to protect health, safety and welfare through the spaces we design. As the George Floyd protests reveal, we’ve failed.
- What We're Reading: Black Live Matter, Urban Oppression and Parks FTW, The Urbanist.
- Whiteness and Planning. Journal of the American Planning Association, March 2020.
- Understanding White Supremacy and How to Defeat It (video)
- Black Lives Don't Matter in APA's Colorblind Planning: APA Rejected Legislative Policy Guide on Criminal Justice | Progressive City: The American Planning Association (APA) views itself as a membership organization that offers opportunity for education and advocacy on behalf of the planning movement. However, the APA is more a trade organization concerned about standardizing the profession rather than challenging its members and the public through education and advocacy on the ability of planning to directly address race and institutional racism. Put another way, the APA neither advocates nor establishes policy for the explicit benefit of the African American community. This explains why many mainstream planners and our premier planning association choose not to promote restructuring of the US criminal justice system.
- Inclusive Planning Processes Quick Notes, David Morley, AICP.
- More and Better: Increasing Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion in Planning, APA PAS Memo by Kendra Smith, PhD.
- Planning With Diverse Communities, PAS Report 593 (Free to non-members and members on the APA website).
- Weaving equity into the planning process, Interaction Institute for Social Change.
- Planning for Equity, Planning Magazine December 2018.
- Tools for Environmental Justice and Equity Planning, APA-Wisconsin - Summer 2015 Newsletter Article.
- Integrating Gender Mainstreaming into U.S. Planning Practice, PAS Memo - November 2019.
Anti-Racism Resource Guides
The Planner’s Equity Toolbox should not be your only guide to racial justice. Other similar resources have been compiled by other individuals and groups. These anti-racism resource guides include more articles, videos, podcasts, books, and organization recommendations to serve as a resource to white people and parents to deepen anti-racism work across a variety of topic areas.
- Anti-racism Resource Guide by Tasha K
- Anti-racism Resources for White People by Sarah Sophie Flicker and Alyssa Klein
Book Recommendations
- The New Jim Crow: Mass Incarceration in the Age of Colorblindness by Michelle Alexander
- Evicted: Poverty & Profit in the American City by Matthew Desmond
- The Color of Law: A Forgotten History of How Our Government Segregated America by Richard Rothstein
Talking To Kids About Race
More Reading
- 97 Things White People Can Do for Racial Justice, Medium.com. This article from 2017 is continuously updated.
- For Our White Friends Desiring to Be Allies, Sojourners, 2017.
- Dear White People, This is What We Want You to Do, Inside the Kandi Dish, 2020.
- Anti Racism Organizing Collective - AROC, Facebook Page
- White Nonsense Roundup - WNR, Facebook Page